I Was in the Room When Survivor 50 Accidentally Spoiled Part of the Finale on Live TV. Here’s What Happened (Exclusive)

Survivor 50 was a season for the record books, and the live finale was no exception.

I was one of the 1,300 people gathered on the Paramount lot in Los Angeles for the live finale and reunion show, set on a stage that was incredibly decorated to evoke the season 50 tribal council temple where the contestants really got their torches snuffed in Fiji during filming last year.

The energy in the room was electric from the jump. The audience — filled with super fans, former winners and even a few celebrity fans like Adam Scott and Nikki Glaser — rose to their feet multiple times to cheer Jeff Probst and the cast as they were introduced. As giant screens showed the pre-recorded elements of the finale, the crowd went from watching intently to applauding during major moments.

After Aubry Bracco won the final four immunity challenge, it was made clear that she was bringing Joe Hunter to the final three to plead their case to the jury. That left Rizo Velovic and Jonathan Young to face off in a fire-making challenge to determine who would claim the last spot at the final tribal council.

Before heading to a commercial break, Probst joined the previously revealed jury members on stage for a live segment. When he brought Rizo out, the audience began to murmur — why were they bringing out Rizo but not Jonathan? After a short exchange, Probst said, “Camp life is also about firemaking. I don’t know if there’s something in there to think about. Anyway, Rizo, you’ve become the final member of the jury. Take a spot over here.”

A collective gasp swept through the audience. Strangers exchanged confused glances. The contestants on stage reacted in surprise as well. We all knew right away that wasn’t supposed to have happened — we had yet to see the fire making challenge air.

Related Stories

Jeff Probst Reveals What Went Through His Mind During His Live-TV Mistake in ‘Survivor 50’ Finale

‘Survivor 50’ Star Rizo Velovic Reacts to Jeff Probst’s Live Finale Blunder: ‘I Was Very Confused’ (Exclusive)

“This is it. These are our people. Their games fell a little short, but this is the group that is going to…” Probst continued.

Then the Emmy-winning host picked up on the energy shift. Contestants tried to tell him that part hadn’t happened yet.

“I’m not even sure what’s happened,” Probst said before the show cut to a commercial break.

My phone started lighting up. I was getting texts from family and friends on the East Coast asking, “What just happened?!” It was clear that the show was, indeed, very live and that the mistake had aired on TV.

After a few minutes of processing what just happened, I perked up as Probst took the stage again after the commercial break, waiting anxiously to see what he would say.

“Alright, so, I love doing live television,” Probst said. “In case you’re confused, this is what happened. We were going to show you fire-making, and then have the loser of fire-making, Rizo, come out and talk about if he had practiced fire-making, maybe he would’ve won. Instead, we did a Survivor twist, it’s the last twist of the season. We call it, ‘A peek into the future.’ So now, we’re going to watch Rizo lose in a fire to Jonathan.”

The audience cheered, then as the fire-making challenge played out on screen, everyone feigned surprise as Jonathan emerged victorious.

Probst explained the next day that he wasn’t watching the episode air during the live finale, and it was clear that somewhere along the way, there was a mistake in the sequence behind the scenes. Instead of bringing out Rizo after the fire-making challenge aired, they brought him in before. Rizo told me after the episode that he was “very confused” during the blunder, realizing what was happening as the moment unfolded. (However, he was thrilled to be a “part of history!”)

Despite the mistake, Probst and the production team handled it as well as they could. They acknowledged the mix-up, laughed about it and moved on. Later in the finale, Probst even asked the audience if they wanted to see the events unfold in the order they actually happened. At the end of the day, the best live TV moments are often the ones nobody planned — and this was certainly one of them.